PDA

View Full Version : REVIEW: Apple IPod


jadison
02-09-2002, 8:44 AM
The impressive IPod MP3 player will become even more appealing with the help of new third-party Windows software.

http://neotech.8m.net/images/ipod.gif

Apple's sleek, white-and-silver IPod is not only the best-looking MP3 player we've seen, it's also the easiest to use--provided you own a Macintosh. But PC users take note: software to make it Windows-compatible is on the way. The IPod's 5GB hard drive lets you fit about a thousand 160-kbps MP3 files into a package no bigger than a deck of cards. The IPod also works as a portable Mac hard drive; with it, you can carry not just your whole music collection in a coat pocket but also most of your critical files, if you like.

Apple was far from the first company to think of using a hard drive for portable music storage. For instance, the Archos Jukebox, which came out earlier, offers even bigger hard drives--from a 6GB, $240 version to a 20GB, $307 model. But the $399 IPod outshines the Jukebox in all other measures: It's about 30 percent smaller, weighs half as much, and feels twice as easy to use.

The IPod's 2-inch LCD screen beautifully displays scads of information. When music is playing, you can easily read the song title, album, artist, duration, and volume information, plus the battery meter. And a brilliant set of controls lets you jump from viewing song information to tweaking the contrast or sleep-timer settings, or to turning on the LCD backlight, in an instant.

The secret to the IPod's design is its clever use of the oldest invention: the wheel. The IPod's main screen lists five key menus, including Playlists, Artists, and Songs. A thumbwheel lets you smoothly scroll up or down the list of items, and pressing the Select button in the center of the wheel advances you to the next level of menus. Pushing the Menu button above the wheel takes you back one level. Buttons to the left and right of the wheel let you jump back or ahead one song. With these simple controls, you can navigate through hundreds of songs in seconds.

And listening to any song, anywhere, is a joy: The IPod's unusually large 32MB buffer kept the music flowing no matter how hard I shook the device. While full-size headphones are still more comfortable, Apple's included earpieces feel better than most, and they sound great. Still, your ears will get sore if you listen long enough, and that's easy to do: Our informal tests backed up Apple's claim that the IPod runs for 10 hours on a charge.

You recharge the built-in battery--and load music--via an IEEE 1394 (FireWire) port, which is far faster than using the USB 1.1 interfaces on other MP3 players. In our tests, we were able to load 117 songs totaling 400MB in 1.5 minutes. The same transfer to an Archos Jukebox with a USB 1.1 interface took just over 10 minutes. To charge the battery when you're away from a computer, you can plug the FireWire cable into the included electrical outlet adapter.

The IPod is not without flaws, however. The moment you pick the unit up, the brilliant stainless-steel backing turns into a mess of fingerprints. A smudge-proof finish, such as brushed aluminum, would look much better.

But many potential customers may never even consider getting their fingers on the device, since they aren't Mac owners. The computer-based player software, ITunes 2.0, works only on the Mac. That's a shame, because it's as intuitively designed as the IPod is for organizing MP3 music, and it includes features such as an equalizer, CD ripping and burning utilities, and the ability to automatically update the IPod's music collection when the device is attached to the system. ITunes will not recognize (and the IPod can't play) songs in other compression formats such as Microsoft WMA or RealAudio, though Apple says it isn't ruling out adding this capability in future software and firmware upgrades.

While I'd consider spending $399 on the IPod, I wouldn't drop an additional $1000 on an iMac just so I could use it. However, the software vendor MediaFour is working on bringing the IPod to the Windows world. Known for its Mac-PC compatibility software MacDrive, MediaFour is now developing Windows-compatible IPod software, called XPlay. We tried alpha versions of XPlay on PCs (with IEEE 1394 cards installed) running Windows XP and 2000. With the software, the PCs recognized the IPod as an external drive under Windows Explorer, and they were able to transfer songs to it via Microsoft Windows Media Player.

The final version, which MediaFour is planning to release at the end of February, will allow Windows Media Player to perform the same key functions as ITunes, such as adding and deleting songs, creating playlists, and syncing the music collections between your IPod and your PC. According to MediaFour, XPlay will sell for under $40 and will work with PCs running Windows 98 SE, Me, 2000, and XP.

Overview:
This is the best-looking, easiest to use MP3 player we've seen, but it's pricey, and third-party Windows support is still in the works.

Price:
Street: $399

Purchasing Info
Click Here (http://pcworld.pricegrabber.com/search_prodsummary.php/masterid=520896/ut=d1016dd2cfc79d32/)

Apple IPod (http://store.apple.com/1-800-MY-APPLE/WebObjects/AppleStore.woa/81/wo/7PlRW1g13tJ7C8nbG6/0.3.0.3.30.17.1.3.1.1.0?190,15)

*Courtesy of PCWorld HERE* (http://www.pcworld.com/reviews/article/0,aid,82204,tk,prx,00.asp)

Herb
02-09-2002, 11:22 AM
Well, nice geek stuff:D

Real geeks paid the 600$ tag 1 1/2 years ago for the Nomad Jukebox 6gigs, a lot of bloatware and a BS of support from Creative:(
But heck, I've paid it and I'm still squeezing it, oh well ;)

Uh, I forgot, I'm in the market for the tiniest CF-MP3 player now, as I've got just a 512MB CF/I card for 230$ for the digicam:D

jadison
02-26-2002, 4:06 PM
Well, I was actually in the market for an MP3 player about a year or so ago...but I chose a SONY MiniDisc player instead, the 1st generation of this model (http://www.bestbuy.com/detail.asp?e=11087529&m=58&cat=61&scat=248). @ the time, it seemed like a better purchase because I had removable media that was accepted in more places than say "Memory Stick", or "CF", etc., and it was more cost efficient for the player and discs in the long run.

Herb
02-27-2002, 2:30 AM
The minidisk system is fine especially for mobile high quality recordings:)
However I'd decided never to buy again any Sony proprieatary stuff again:(

The HD-based players are good for holiday trips and a bit more stationary usage, though you can walk with them. I found the 6GB more than adequate to hold stuff you really want to listen to.

For more mobility, I got also a MP3-cd player (Elta, probably unknown to America), and an Aiwa Car MP3 headunit. Not to mention my new external CDRW-burner Jack-Rabitt, which can play MP3 stand alone on 12V supply:D

I've opted for a CF solution now, because I needed more space for the digi cam anyway and it was a steal:) I can use the CF also later with other geeky stuff to come up;)
The unit I've in mind at the moment is here
http://www.mydivaplayer.com/HTML/features.html
Especially the internal 128MB version + CF read/write through USB is good:)

All external units I use must have AA NiMH cabability, as I have 5*4 sets of 1200-1800mA of them.

robin801
10-29-2002, 7:45 PM
herb==i was wondering if u have purchased the above mp3 player?

how do u like it?

i am looking to buy one for xmas.

Herb
10-30-2002, 12:04 PM
I bought finally the 224MB version and it's simply great, though I had problems with a 512MB extra card. Bought a 256MB instead:)
All the keys are worn out already:D, I've used it since springtime nearly every day several times.

When you exchange files (very easy, just another drive letter) and disconnect the cable, you've first to start it in normal playing mode than power down, before you can reconnect it to mama again. That's nowhere documented, cost me a bit to find it out;)